The Shelf Verdict
The Shelf Verdict

INDEPENDENT REVIEWS & EDITORIAL

THE FORMULA & THE FEEL

The Skincare Shelf

What delivers, what delights, and what deserves its place.

Filter by
Brand
Product type
Verdict
Sort: Newest first

Serum

Mothered

Silk Factor Serum

An ambitious, beautifully formulated serum that makes a compelling case for doing more with less.

Face Mask

Laurel

Honey Berry Mask

A beautiful-looking botanical mask that turned out to be considerably less enjoyable to use than I’d hoped.

Serum

Maya Chia

The Super Lift

A beautifully formulated antioxidant serum with plenty to offer, if not the instant lift its name suggests.

Face Oil

Lepaar

Zen Matcha Cashmere

Beautifully presented, thoughtfully sourced, and considerably less extraordinary than its description would have you believe.

New verdicts, by email.

A short letter when new reviews and essays are published. Nothing else.